Judging Religion
A Dialogue for Our Time
John Holroyd
John Holroyd's dissection of religion and what it means today.
- ISBN 9781781328637
- Published Sep 2019
- 210 x 148mm (312 pages)
- Also available as:
£29.99
There is good reason why some people don’t want to talk about religion in polite company. Like conversations about politics, discussions about religion all too often set people at odds with each other in ways that are hard to predict and difficult to control.
For all the controversy involved with such debate, this book invites the reader to engage with an ethical appraisal of religion(s) as they are practised today. It is written in the belief that this is an important dialogue for our time. It claims, despite the emotive character of the subject, that the free exchange of ideas and experience between people of differing views and commitments can with practice generate more light than heat.
Particular effort is made to answer the question: how can we fairly evaluate the ethical character of religion(s)? It focuses especially but not at all exclusively on the religions of Christianity and Islam, being critical of them in many respects; but it also offers sharp rebuke to some of the perspectives of Richard Dawkins and others among the new atheists.
Want to read it in other formats?
Judging Religion is also available as a hardback and on Amazon Kindle.

Originally from North Yorkshire, John Holroyd studied philosophy, theology and religious studies at King’s College, London in the 1980s. He has since taught religious studies and philosophy in both state and independent schools and was Head of Religious Studies at St. Dunstan’s College in south London for over twenty years. He currently lectures at the London School of Philosophy and teaches philosophy for the Workers’ Educational Association. He has published articles with
Philosophy Now magazine and
The Ethical Review.
'What are we to make of religion? It is so varied and so influential in cultures and in the private lives of billions. So many aspects of religions are problematic yet it seems unclear how and how far people not sharing particular faiths are able to criticise them. This is the subject matter of Holroyd’s book. This is an urgent book on a vital subject and it deserves to be widely read. It is clearly written, carefully argued, motivated by universal goodwill yet unafraid of tackling bitterly controversial topics.' – Rick Lewis, Philosophy Now
Read Julian Bond's review of
Judging Religion in Medium
here.
Take a look at Julian's review in the
Methodist Recorder here.
Read the Advance Information sheet for
Judging Religion: a Dialogue for Our Time here.
“If you’re thinking of self-publishing, I hope you don't go at it alone. With a team like SilverWood behind you, you have the support you need to publish the best work you believe in.”
J A Higgins